justice and law
Justice is the supposed moral and impartial treatment of all peoples and the desire by all to do what is deemed to be “right” by society. It is the concept that our laws are based upon, but can true justice come from the law? The law is an all-encompassing assumption about a specific circumstance and the actions to be carried out thereafter. It is a guideline that does not take into account the specifics of a particular case. It is defined by Webster’s as “a binding custom or practice of a community; a rule of conduct or action prescribed or formally recognized as binding or enforced by a controlling authority.” Law clearly states the way things are to be handled and how punishment goes once the line of the law is crossed. It is a fabrication of the human mind whereas justice stems from the soul. Justice deals with the morality of a person and how their actions warrant a specific consequence. It is based on exact circumstances and it is need based, not prescribed like law. Stemming from morality, justice thus stems from the determining factor of morality, religion. A person’s moral fabric is determined, often times, by the teachings of religion, creating somebody who will hopefully be able to distinguish between right and wrong. The morality of Christians is determined by the Ten Commandments, which inevitably are the basis for all law in this country. This fact inexplicably links justice and law within our society, but not necessarily in another. At the end of the movie version of Billy Budd, a quote was uttered by the narrator to the effect of, “Justice will live as long as the human soul, the law as long as the human mind.” Justice, being determined by a person’s morality, is then based upon the societal factors that determine that fact. Law is based on the human desire to protect itself from being wronged and to punish those who do wrong us.